Paula Poe critically hurt in pedestrian crash on Gulf Boulevard

Authorities say driver fled after striking woman in St. Pete Beach

March 25, 2026 | St Pete Beach, FL

Paula Poe, 56, sustained life-threatening injuries in a hit-and-run collision on Gulf Boulevard in St. Pete Beach on March 25. The Pinellas County Sheriff's Office reported that deputies arrived at the scene around 9 p.m. to find Poe on the curb after being struck by a fleeing vehicle.

Paula Poe, 56, was seriously injured after being struck by a vehicle in a hit-and-run crash on Gulf Boulevard in St. Pete Beach.

The driver had sped away southbound, scattering debris across the road. Investigators followed the trail of debris to a 2019 Cadillac Escalade parked at a hotel lot in nearby Tierra Verde. The vehicle's operator, Margaret Barah Gardner, 43, exhibited clear signs of impairment and failed field sobriety tests.

Authorities arrested Gardner, charging her with driving under the influence, refusal to submit to testing, and leaving the scene of a crash involving serious bodily injury. The Pinellas County Sheriff's Office Major Accident Investigation Team is leading the ongoing investigation into the circumstances surrounding the crash.

What Happened in the St. Pete Beach Hit-and-Run?

Key details from the incident include:

• Date and Time: March 25, approximately 9 p.m.
• Location: Gulf Boulevard, St. Pete Beach, Florida
• Victim: Paula Poe, 56, found with critical injuries on the roadside
• Vehicle Involved: 2019 Cadillac Escalade, which fled the scene southbound
• Debris Trail: Led investigators to the suspect vehicle in a Tierra Verde hotel parking lot
• Driver Condition: Margaret Barah Gardner, 43, showed impairment and performed poorly on sobriety tests

Why Do Hit-and-Run Crashes Like This Occur?

Hit-and-run incidents often stem from drivers attempting to evade responsibility, particularly when impaired. In this case, the driver's flight left Poe in grave condition, highlighting the dangers of roadways in popular coastal areas like St. Pete Beach. Such collisions underscore the need for heightened vigilance and swift law enforcement response.

Charges Against the Suspect Driver

Margaret Barah Gardner faces multiple serious charges:

• Driving under the influence
• Refusal to submit to chemical testing
• Leaving the scene of a crash with serious bodily injury

These accusations reflect the gravity of operating a vehicle while impaired and fleeing accountability.

Legal Insights on Impaired Driving Crashes

Newsline consulted national legal analysts for their perspective on motor vehicle incidents involving impairment.

"Drunken and drugged drivers face criminal charges after accidents that harm or kill others," said Candice Bond, managing partner at Bond Legal. "In cases such as this, victims' families may pursue compensation via civil lawsuits against the at-fault party."

Key takeaways from analyst insights:

• Impaired driving remains a leading cause of preventable roadway tragedies.
• Criminal penalties can include fines, license suspension, and imprisonment.
• Civil claims help cover medical expenses, lost wages, and emotional distress.
• Victims should consult professionals to navigate insurance challenges.

Stefano Formica, of counsel with Bond Legal, added:

"Injured parties in collisions frequently file personal injury claims to address medical costs, ongoing care, income loss, and suffering. Insurance providers often minimize payouts, but legal support ensures fair recovery."

Hit-and-Run and DUI Accident Statistics

According to the National Safety Council, impaired driving contributes significantly to roadway fatalities. Below is a summary of key data:

These figures emphasize the urgent need for awareness and enforcement to reduce such preventable incidents.

Newsline, a premier digital news platform owned by Belsito Communications, Inc., upholds rigorous editorial standards with an unwavering commitment to journalistic integrity and editorial excellence. 

For transparency, view our Corrections Policy, which guarantees a 24-hour review of any submitted concerns.

(This report is based on verified data - learn more on our About Us page.)

Newsline - is your trusted source for legal news and accident reports, delivering timely updates to keep you informed.