Cynthia Sitterle dies in pedestrian hit-and-run on Kensington Avenue

Jeep Compass struck pedestrian near Harlem Road intersection

December 20, 2025 | Amherst, NY

A tragic hit-and-run incident claimed the life of 70-year-old Cynthia Sitterle from Cheektowaga on Kensington Avenue in Amherst, New York. 

Authorities report the pedestrian was struck by a vehicle around 6 p.m., leading to the driver's arrest on serious charges.

What Happened in the Crash?

Cynthia Sitterle, 70, of Cheektowaga died after a Jeep Compass struck her as a pedestrian on Kensington Avenue near Harlem Road in Amherst.

Police detailed the sequence of the crash leading to this fatal accident:

• Victim Details: Cynthia Sitterle, 70, was walking near the intersection of Kensington Avenue and Harlem Road.
• Incident Time and Location: The collision occurred at approximately 6 p.m. on Dec. 20 in front of 1970 Kensington Ave.
• Vehicle Involved: A Jeep Compass struck Sitterle, who succumbed to her injuries at the scene.
• Driver's Actions: The driver fled but was quickly located at her home and taken into custody.

This devastating crash underscores the dangers pedestrians face on busy roadways.

Why Was the Driver Arrested?

Following a swift investigation by Amherst police, the driver faced multiple charges:

• Driving while intoxicated
• Leaving the scene of a fatal motor vehicle accident
• Second-degree vehicular manslaughter

If convicted, the driver could receive a sentence of up to seven years in prison. The case remains under active investigation as authorities gather more evidence.

How Prevalent Are Pedestrian Fatalities?

Pedestrian deaths have surged in recent years, driven by factors like larger vehicles, inadequate infrastructure, and risky driving behaviors. The Governors Highway Safety Association's 2024 preliminary report documented 7,148 pedestrian fatalities nationwide.

These statistics highlight the urgent need for improved road safety measures to protect vulnerable road users.

Legal Insights on Pedestrian Accidents

National legal analysts provide valuable perspectives on incidents like hit-and-run crashes involving pedestrians.

“In cases such as this, road conditions, signage visibility, and lighting must be thoroughly examined to determine contributing factors,” said Candice Bond, managing partner at Bond Legal. “Pedestrians generally have the right of way at intersections, even outside marked crosswalks, making it critical to investigate all elements for justice.”

Key takeaways from analyst insights include:

• Drivers must yield to pedestrians to prevent avoidable tragedies.
• Families may pursue wrongful death claims for losses like income, companionship, and emotional distress.
• Evidence collection is time-sensitive, and prompt legal review ensures fair outcomes.
• Insurance firms often push for low settlements—professional advocacy is essential for equitable compensation.

“It is almost always a driver’s duty to yield to any pedestrian in similar scenarios,” noted Stefano Formica, of counsel at Bond Legal. “Affected families deserve comprehensive support to navigate the aftermath.”

Newsline, owned by Belsito Communications, Inc., upholds rigorous editorial standards as a premier digital news platform with an unwavering commitment to journalistic integrity and editorial excellence. Our reporting draws from verified data and reputable sources like the CDC and Federal Highway Administration. For transparency, review our Corrections Policy, which guarantees a 24-hour response to any concerns.

Interested in reaching a targeted audience? Advertise with Newsline to connect with readers in the insurance, automotive, and legal sectors.

(This report is based on verified data - learn more on our About Us page.)

Newsline - is your trusted source for legal news and accident reports, delivering timely updates to keep you informed.