Barbara Koontz killed in pedestrian crash on West Sixth Street

GMC 2500 Denali struck Florence woman retrieving trampoline in Muscle Shoals

April 12, 2026 | Muscle Shoals, AL

A devastating hit-and-run incident on West Sixth Street resulted in the death of 67-year-old Barbara Ann Koontz from Florence. 

Authorities arrested 31-year-old Brett Wilson Black in connection with the collision that occurred on April 12.

Barbara Ann Koontz, 67, died after she was hit by a GMC 2500 Denali while attempting to retrieve a trampoline from the roadway on West Sixth Street in Muscle Shoals.

What Happened in the Crash?

Police responded to reports of a pedestrian struck in the 400 block of West Sixth Street. Koontz was retrieving a trampoline that had fallen from her Chevrolet 1500 when a speeding GMC 2500 Denali struck her as she attempted to return to her vehicle.

• Date: April 12
• Location: 400 block of West Sixth Street, Muscle Shoals, AL
• Victim: Barbara Ann Koontz, 67, of Florence
• Vehicles Involved: Chevrolet 1500, victim's, GMC 2500 Denali, suspect's
• Suspect: Brett Wilson Black, 31
• Injuries/Outcome: Koontz was airlifted to Huntsville Hospital and pronounced dead upon arrival
• Charges: Criminally negligent homicide, leaving the scene of an accident resulting in death
• Bond: $25,000 at Colbert County Jail

The driver briefly stopped to inspect the GMC for damage before fleeing. Investigators later found the suspect vehicle abandoned in a Prattville hotel parking lot. Black was captured 11 days later through a multi-agency effort and is being held in Colbert County Jail.

The Muscle Shoals Police Department continues its investigation into the circumstances surrounding the fatal collision.

Why Do Hit-and-Run Accidents Happen?

Hit-and-run crashes remain a persistent issue on U.S. roadways, often driven by fear of consequences or impaired judgment. According to the Federal Highway Administration, these incidents contribute significantly to road safety challenges.

Legal Insights

National legal analysts emphasize the importance of thorough investigations in hit-and-run cases to ensure accountability and support for affected families.

“In cases such as this, conducting an independent investigation promptly is crucial to protect victims' rights and prove negligence,” said Candice Bond, managing partner of Bond Legal. “Factors like road conditions, visibility, and lighting must be examined to build a strong case.”

Key takeaways from analyst perspectives on motor vehicle crashes:

• Independent investigations can uncover hidden evidence overlooked by initial reports.
• Proving fault in hit-and-runs often requires professional analysis of vehicle dynamics and scene reconstruction.
• Families deserve compensation for losses, including emotional distress and financial impacts.

“The grief following a loved one's death in an accident can be immense,” said Stefano Formica, of counsel at Bond Legal. “A dedicated lawyer helps families navigate investigations and safeguards their interests throughout the process.”

Pending further details, Koontz's family may explore a wrongful death claim to seek damages for companionship loss, suffering, and distress.

Newsline's Commitment to Credibility

Newsline, owned by Belsito Communications, Inc., stands as a premier digital news platform with an unwavering commitment to journalistic integrity and editorial excellence. Our rigorous standards ensure accurate, timely reporting on legal and public safety matters. 

For transparency, review our Corrections Policy, which guarantees a 24-hour response to any concerns.

(This report is based on verified data - learn more on our About Us page.)

Newsline - is your trusted source for legal news and accident reports, delivering timely updates to keep you informed.