Toothman’s Buick ran a stop sign before being struck by a bus on Ohio 301
November 18, 2025 | Carlisle Township, OH
A devastating crash in Carlisle Township claimed the life of Allan Toothman from LaGrange and injured two others when his vehicle collided with a school bus.
The incident occurred at the intersection of Parsons Road and Ohio 301, highlighting the dangers of intersection mishaps.
Allan Toothman, 61, of LaGrange, died after his Buick ran a stop sign and collided with a school bus at Parsons Road and Ohio 301 in Carlisle Township.
What Happened in the Crash?
The Ohio State Highway Patrol responded to the scene around 9:30 a.m. A 2006 Buick, driven by 61-year-old Allan Toothman, was heading east on Parsons Road. The driver failed to stop at the intersection stop sign, leading to a collision with a southbound Keystone Local School District bus. The impact caused the bus to overturn.
- Location: Parsons Road and Ohio 301, Carlisle Township, Ohio
- Vehicles Involved: 2006 Buick sedan and Keystone Local School District school bus
- Time of Incident: Approximately 9:30 a.m.
- Contributing Factor: Failure to yield at stop sign
Injuries and Emergency Response
Allan Toothman was rushed to a nearby hospital but unfortunately passed away due to his injuries. The school bus carried only the driver, a 47-year-old from LaGrange, and a 51-year-old aide from Elyria. Both were wearing seatbelts and suffered injuries that were not life-threatening. They were taken to University Hospitals Elyria Medical Center for treatment. Importantly, no students were on the bus at the time.
Crash Summary |
Details |
|---|
Victim |
Allan Toothman, 61, LaGrange, OH (Fatal) |
Bus Occupants |
Driver (47, LaGrange, OH) and Aide (51, Elyria, OH) - Non-life-threatening injuries |
Agency |
Ohio State Highway Patrol |
Investigation Status |
Ongoing |
Why Do These Accidents Happen?
Intersections are high-risk areas for motor vehicle crashes. According to the Federal Highway Administration, about 40% of car collisions occur at intersections, often due to drivers running stop signs or signals. Common causes include:
- Impatience leading to hasty decisions
- Reckless driving behaviors
- Distracted driving, such as phone use
Intersection Crash Statistics |
Source: Federal Highway Administration |
|---|
Percentage of Collisions at Intersections |
40% |
Primary Causes |
Running stop signs/lights, speeding |
Annual U.S. Intersection Fatalities |
Over 7,000 (recent estimates) |
These factors underscore the need for vigilant driving and thorough investigations to prevent future tragedies.
Legal Insights
In cases such as this involving intersection collisions, independent reviews play a crucial role in understanding the full circumstances.
“It is imperative to determine the exact cause of these types of accidents. Resources like witnesses, background checks, and witness location can provide clarity. We guide families through this complex process,” said Candice Bond, managing partner with Bond Legal.
Key takeaways from analyst perspectives:
- Review police reports alongside insurance details to identify contributing factors
- Hire specialists to reconstruct events and assess liability
- Support injured parties in pursuing claims for medical costs, lost wages, and emotional distress
Stefano Formica, of counsel at Bond Legal, added:
“Injured victims in collisions may seek claims covering medical bills, future care, income loss, and pain. Insurance firms often minimize payouts, so professional advocacy ensures fair compensation.”
Newsline, owned by Belsito Communications, Inc., is a premier digital news platform with an unwavering commitment to journalistic integrity and editorial excellence. Our rigorous standards ensure verified reporting—learn more about our Corrections Policy with a 24-hour review guarantee.
Interested in reaching audiences on traffic safety and legal news? Advertise with Newsline.
(This report is based on verified data - learn more on our About Us page.)
Newsline - is your trusted source for legal news and accident reports, delivering timely updates to keep you informed.
Candice Bond, national legal analyst for Newsline, is experienced in serious auto accidents. She offers free consultations for those in need of help.
(Candice Bond, our national legal analyst, is a Managing Partner at Bond Legal. Newsline can and does use quotes from prior interviews with our analysts for our news articles. If you would like to contact Bond Legal to help you, please call 866-985-6515 or use the submission box found on this page. Legal analysts quoted may or may not be licensed in your state).